トモウ流オカマ先生とアントニーがネットラジオやったらしい。
あのひと本当に目立ちたがりやだね。
たぶんチョ忍よりそのあたり重症じゃないか？

CHRIS JACOBSON IS AFRAID OF QUESTIONS, I GET HUNG UP ON
で、このネットラジオでリスナーからの質問を電話で受けるという企画をやったらしいんだが、ディーンがかけたら速攻切られたとのこと。
こういうところが宗家病らしいというか、カルト教祖的というか。

で、このスレに面白い書き込みがあった。
アントニー自身の書き込みなんだが

I have talked to Christa dean and the reason i am not "attacking" is because she is bringing out a book with her history in.
私がクリスタを攻撃しないのは彼女自身の記録を記した本を持ってきたからだ。

ハァ？
この人一体どうしてしまったんだ？
自叙伝を持ってくればオッケーなのか？
だったら初見も髙松も何の問題も無かったじゃないか？

I wonder why Antony(or Yoshie?) omitted "If you copy me, you can draw 5,6 shaku long Katana." from Zohyo Monogatari.
Dean pointed out the part proved the Katana described on Zohyo Monogatari was before Tokugawa Bakufu regulated Katana length.
If so, Antony's logic-Illustrations on Zohyo Monogatari reflect mid Edo period.-doesn't work?

クリスタ・ジャコブソン先生は資料捏造にもかなり力を入れていて偽流派の免許も作ってます。この点非常に某半島民族のウリジナル精神に近いですね。
あきらかに習字の出来る人に頼んでますが日本人じゃなさそうですね。
習字を学んだ外人ぽい。

日本人は英語の固有名詞をローマ字読みするので「くりすだやこびすん」にはならない。JをY読みするのってドイツだっけ？
年号が西暦で順序が間違っていてしかも零零はありえない。
あきらかに直訳しかできない外人が書いてる。
最後の先生とおぼしき人の名前は大地影、マンガすぎる。
第一本人はコバヤシイチロー先生に師事したと言ってるのだから笑える。
判子の位置もおかしい。









Bullshido
Tomo Ryu 'Menkyo Kaiden' claim

Ok I'm new to this site, but love the work you guys have been doing shining light on false claims. I respect people with martial skills and despise those that try to decieve for whatever end/profit.

Anyway I have read this whole Christa Jacobson thread today and would like to point out some 'irregularities' on the whole Tomo Ryu Bullnindoodoo. The following is based on looking at the photographs from the gallery at www.budoryuninjutsu.com claiming to be the menkyo kaiden of Tomo Ryu. (If there is a close up of this certificate I would like to see it)

It appears that this certificate is supposed to read (Downwards Right to left) "Menkyo - Christa Jacobson - Tomo Ryu Nin/Shinobi Jutsu - November 20th 2005 - Name of Teacher"

On the plus side the author seems to know kanji, the characters for Tomo Ryu are 'door', 'fierce' and 'school'

Ok now the problems:
1 - the name is written in Hiragana, not Katakana. Katakana is used for foreign names and imported modern words in the Japanese language. Hiragana is used for Japanese words, as aides to pronunciation or clarification in more modern writings. (Sometimes Japanese like to spell some words in Katakana as this makes them seem 'cool' and foreign - just like Westerners loving to get Chinese and Japanese tattoos)
2 - the characters in the name spell ku-ri-su-da ya-ko-bi-su-n. As hiragana and katakana is phonetic is seems odd that the name isn't JEI-ko-BU-su-n ジェコブスン (the bu has a soft b' sound here as oppossed to the longer 'b-oo' as in Bushido)
3 - the date is written in an American English format (Month-Day-Year), and not a Japanese format (Year-Month-Day)
4 - the kanji for the year uses the characters for the numerals 2-0-0-5, where the 0s use the old legal characters instead of the common modern circle - this shows some knowledge of Japanese - BUT, hang on a minute, Japanese have their own calendar which you would see, especially on a document with the gravitas of Menkyo Kaiden of an ancient school of martial knowledge. The date should be Heisei 17.
5 - Who is the author of the document? The name is at the bottom left - the first two characters look like TEN-CHI, the third, EI/kage, so the name is Heaven-Earth-Shadow 天地影. [影 can be read as EI or kage meaning shadow, silhouette, figure, phantom, trace] - I would like to see the close up to confirm this. So who is Tenchi Ei? This could be a warrior namenickname for Jacobson's teacher - however I have not seen any mention of this on budoryuninjutsu websites. Also you would expect to see the proper name written next to this nickname on the document.

6 - Most importantly, this document is not valid. The 'authors' stamp has been placed next to the authors 'name' - for those that don't know for a document to be legitimate the writer's/author's name stamp is stamped over their name (not vice-versa) - this is done precisely to prevent fraud as name stamps are made for the individual (and registered with the government). For a genuine Japanese person to make this kind of mistake is unthinkable... however for a non-Japanese person who doesn't want to jumble things up and make a document clear cut with a sense of divisions and proper layout...

7 - overall the kanji looks a little contrived:
i - the TO 戸 character in the school name does not have a flowing line as the brush is swept down, the line has an odd curvature
ii - the school name on the two densho in the foreground have the kanji sloping to the left as you go down.
This is indicative of a western style pen grip, where the base of the hand rests on the writing surface and the writing implement slopes down leftwards to the paper. Whereas in the use of a brush for Japanese script the brush is held vertically with the hand off the writing surface.

So who wrote this document - it could possibly be a person of Japanese origin, albeit one who has very questionable gaps in their knowledge, say from a generation or two living in the US, but then if they are forgetting their origin then what does that say for their special secret ninja training. Or a Westerner that has been learning Japanese and wants to be a real life hollywood ninja-master grandmoff blah blah.

For anyone that has the means to invesitigate further - get a decent image of the large red seal on the top right of the document - these seals are made by registered smiths and registered with various institutions in Japan - I would be interested to see what the seal characters say.


Anyway thanks for reading all this. I really hope I havn't made any spelling mistakes as Jacobson's poor spelling and grammar really pisses me off. And just so you know, I'm not Japanese but have lived in Japan since 2003.

画像使わせていただきました日本刀研究家の方のブログ http://nihontoutorekisi.blog.nanto-e.com/detail-2165.html

Antony falls dark ninjer side.

here you can see the whole illustrations of the books.
i'd rather let everyone think by themselves.
the book zohyo monogatari (ashigaru story) is episodes of ashigaru in sengoku period.
the book was written in edo period and had many copies.
there were also many different versions since some were hand copied.
the illustrations are, as you see, not good.
some ashigaru has curved wakizashi and straight daito, some has reverse.
the reason why they were mostly straight swords was the original illustrator wasn't good artist.
that's my analysis.
ashigaru were usually dirt poor. they join the army just because they could eat white rice. they get swords by looting or picking from dead soldiers.
after katanagari, daimyo provided swords and those were mass produced cheap ones, it's hardly believe daimyo to buy chokuto(straight sword) specially for ashigaru.
none of japanese historians ever said some ashigaru used chokuto just because of the illustrations.

Antony seems to have no knowledge about Bakumatsu.
Ashigaru in 1800's with full armor and chokuto?
I asked "Are you talking about Boshin war or Seinan war?"
He wasn't able to answer.

コニグン忍術の次ぐらいに笑えるかな。
突っ込みいれたら「武道流というのは団体名だ、武神館と同じだ。」と言うので日本語がさっぱりわかってないだね。
つまり戸隠流武神館のように戸猛流武道流だって言いたいらしい、「流」の意味がわかってない。

公式サイト
http://www.budoryuninjutsu.com/
によると

戸猛流は建武の新政時代に小太刀と古武器に特化した流派として近江で始まって、創始者の名前はトモウゴヘエとトモウジンスケとアクタガワセンリ。
戦国時代に入り謀略、諜報、隠遁術がさかんになり、これが後に戸猛流忍術と知られるようになる。

もちろん全部デタラメですねｗ
でもよく勉強しましたね。
Tomo Ryu Shinobijutsu なのに漢字はなぜか(戸隠流忍術)になってるところなどドジっこぶりが垣間見えますね。

で、一番笑えるのはこの系図にあるナカシマハヤシ先生でしょうｗｗ
2005年まで生きてたらしいですよｗ


で、コバヤシイチロー先生（2008年死亡）が未来を託した女性、それが武道流宗家クリスタ・ジャコブソン、ある意味今流行の男の娘。ただしガチムチ。

Budo ryu 武道流 Budo means martial art so the ryuha name means "martial art scool"
Antony Cummins(he's now cooperating with it) said

i have already addressed this. Budo Ryu is not a Japanese art. It is the name of her school, like Bujinkan.

That doesn't make sense.
Bujinkan is now a big school name but it's named traditional way.
For example, Hokushin Itto ryu - Genbukan, Shindo Munen ryu - Renpeikan.
So Togakure ryu - Bujinkan is OK, but Tomo ryu - Budo ryu is wrong.
Both are ryuha name.
Since Antony admitted his lack of understanding Japanese, I'm not surprised but he can't tell people it's the correct way.

budoryuninjutsu.com

According to legend Tomo Ryu Shinobijutsu (戸隠流忍術)was developed in the Kemmu Restoration (建武の新政)

It says Tomo ryu but the kanji is Togakure ryu 戸隠流.
What kind of trick is that?

Here's CJ's imaginary sensei Kobayashi Ichiro.The name sounds like John Smith, very very common name.


"Years later he met a woman that he passed down the knowledge"
Though the woman don't look woman. So manly.


I am going to write about Budo ryu in Japanese to let J-people know how ninjers distort our history.

忍術研究家のアントニーさんが初見良昭氏の本から見つけました。
実物はhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5X0_2V­gqmmcの7:30あたりで見られます。
実演してくれる勇者募集。


戦国忍法図鑑てトンデモ本ですな。
こんな本を有難がるようでは駄目だ。